The hunters and the surrender of dignity
An anthropologist’s notes on the Maritime lobster supper.
By Sébastien Després
I’d spent a fortnight among these people before I understood that what I was witnessing wasn’t a practice but a ritual, and many moons before I understood it wasn’t one ceremony but several, linked across land and sea and season. It involves permissions older than the memory of the living, tools unchanged in centuries, a calendar enforced with the severity of scripture, and, at its conclusion, the voluntary and total surrender of dignity. I questioned the villagers. I questioned their guests. No one could explain what they were doing. They laughed when I pressed them. In my experience, that’s the surest sign of genuine ritual: the people performing it have no idea they’re performing anything at all.
The great permission
No one may undertake the hunt without written dispensation from the Great Sovereign. There are a fixed number of permissions in existence, and no new ones are made. They pass from parent to child, and they’re often worth considerably more than the vessels that carry the hunters. In certain territories a single permission changes hands for the price of the finest of houses. One doesn’t just decide to hunt this animal. One inherits the privilege, or buys it from someone who did.
The season
The hunt is permitted only in certain seasons, proclaimed by the Sovereign to the day and hour. Before the appointed morning, the creature is untouchable. After the final evening, untouchable again. A holy man of the settlement blesses the vessels and their hunters. I couldn’t determine whether the blessing protects the hunters from the sea, the sea from the hunters, or the creature from some fate worse than capture. At daybreak on the first morning, the hunters set out frantically into the creature’s territory.
The colours
The hunters leave boxes on long lines marked with floating heraldry. Each colour belongs to one family. To disturb another hunter’s colours is a serious transgression. The codes aren’t written in any book of law I could find. They don’t need to be.
The judgement
When the boxes come up, the hunter holds a piece of metal against each creature. Those that pass are kept. Those that fail go back to the sea. Females bearing young are returned too, but first they’re marked by the hunter, which consecrates them as bearers of future generations, belonging to no one hunter but to the continuance of the species.
The vestment
At the table, a thin ritual garment is fastened around the participant’s neck. It often bears the likeness of the very creature about to be consumed. Whether this is tribute, mockery, or sympathetic magic, I can’t say. Every time I asked, people laughed. Laughter isn’t an answer, but it’s frequently the most honest response available.
The implements
A hinged metal instrument for fracturing the casing. A slender probe for flesh in cavities too narrow for fingers. Sometimes shears. Laid beside a place setting, the full set wouldn’t look out of place in a surgeon’s bag.
The sacred liquid
A small vessel of golden liquid sits beside the plate: rendered fat, heated just below translucence. Every fragment of flesh is submerged in it before it reaches the mouth, with the regularity of a genuflection. Extract, dip, consume. When I asked one participant why, she said, “This is the way we do it here,” which isn’t an explanation, but it’s the closest thing to theology this ritual possesses.
The schism
At some point the participant meets the creature’s digestive gland. It divides these people more sharply than any political, religious, or linguistic question I’ve met in thirty years of travel. One faction eats it with reverence. The other won’t acknowledge it exists. There are no moderates.
The transformation
By now the participant’s hands, forearms, and chin are coated in rendered fat and the creature’s fluids. Fragments of casing have gathered on the table, on the vestment, and occasionally in the hair. And here I must record the observation that changed what I believed I was witnessing. Nobody cares. The person who arrived in fine clothes, who adjusted their place setting before sitting down, is now wearing the likeness of the creature, holding a fragment of its casing in one hand and a metal probe in the other, with butter on their chin, and they’re smiling. Not performing. Just smiling. The ritual has done something to them I’ve rarely seen among any people I’ve lived with: it has removed, temporarily and completely, the possibility of dignity.
I believe this may be the entire point.
The maternal feast
Once a year, on a day consecrated to the maternal figure, entire families gather and the creature is the central offering of the meal. I found it striking that the animal chosen to honour mothers is the one this community pursues, captures, and dismembers with its bare hands. When I raised this, I was told not to overthink it.
In eighth grade, our homeroom teacher, Alvin, had us read Horace Miner’s “Body Ritual Among the Nacirema.” It described a people’s customs with such earnest fascination that I read the whole thing before I realised Miner was describing me. My bathroom. My toothbrush. I don’t know exactly what it did to me. But two decades later I was working on a PhD in anthropology, on ritual and pilgrimage.
How to eat a lobster, the short version
- Twist off the claws and knuckles; crack them with the cracker, and push the meat out with the pick.
- Hold the body and tail, bend the tail back until it comes free, then push the tail meat out in one piece.
- The green tomalley is the digestive gland. Some love it, some won’t touch it. Both camps are certain.
- Dip every piece in the warm butter. Wear the bib. Give up on looking dignified early; it saves time.
Before the supperHomarus, a true and faithful account of the lobster
Quick answers
How do you eat a lobster?
Twist off the claws and crack them, then bend the tail back to free it and push the meat out in one piece. Dip each piece in warm butter, and wear the bib.
What is the green stuff in a lobster?
The tomalley, the lobster’s digestive gland. Some people love it and some won’t touch it.
